Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Sweet Home Advisor earns from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Most water heater problems come down to a handful of causes: a tripped breaker or reset button, a failed heating element or thermostat (electric), a pilot or thermocouple problem (gas), sediment and scale in the tank, a worn anode rod, or a leaking valve or tank. This guide walks through each symptom, what usually causes it and what you can safely check yourself before calling a plumber.
Safety first
- Smell gas? Don’t touch switches or try to relight anything. Leave the house and call your gas company or 911 from outside.
- Electric heater: turn off the breaker before removing any access panel; there are 240 volts inside.
- Water pooling around the tank bottom often means the tank itself is leaking, which can’t be repaired. Shut off the water and power or gas.
- Hot water burns: let the tank cool before draining or opening valves.
Water heater troubleshooting chart
| Symptom | Most likely causes | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| No hot water (electric) | Tripped breaker, tripped high-limit reset, failed upper element or thermostat | Breaker; red reset button behind the upper panel |
| No hot water (gas) | Pilot out, faulty thermocouple or flame sensor, gas supply off | Pilot window; gas valve setting |
| Not enough hot water / runs out fast | Failed lower element, thermostat set low, sediment, broken dip tube, heater too small | Thermostat setting; when the heater was last flushed |
| Water too hot | Thermostat set too high or stuck | Set to about 120°F; test at the faucet |
| Rumbling, popping or banging | Sediment buildup on the tank bottom | Flush the tank |
| Rotten egg smell from hot water only | Sulfate in the water reacting with a magnesium anode rod | Replace the anode with an aluminum or powered anode |
| Rusty or discolored hot water | Corroding tank or worn anode rod | Anode rod condition and the heater’s age |
| Leaking from the relief valve pipe | Excess temperature or pressure, faulty T&P valve, thermal expansion | Water temperature; expansion tank |
| Leaking from the bottom | Loose drain valve or failed tank | Drain valve; if the tank leaks, replace the heater |
| Low hot water pressure | Sediment or scale in the heater, pipes or aerators | Compare hot vs cold pressure; clean aerators |
No hot water from an electric water heater
- Check the circuit breaker. Electric heaters use a dedicated 240V double breaker. If it has tripped, reset it once. If it trips again, call an electrician or plumber. See what size breaker a water heater needs.
- Press the reset button. With the power off, remove the upper access panel and insulation and press the red high-limit (ECO) reset button. A.O. Smith notes that if it clicks, the water got too hot and the safety cut-off tripped. A reset that keeps tripping points to a faulty thermostat or shorted element.
- Test the elements. With the power off and wires disconnected, a multimeter set to resistance should read about 5 to 25 ohms across a good element, typically around 12.5 (A.O. Smith). An open or near-zero reading means a failed element.
- Replace the upper thermostat if the upper element is good but still doesn’t heat.
Not comfortable working with 240 volts? A plumber can test and replace elements and thermostats, which are inexpensive parts.
No hot water from a gas water heater
- Check the pilot. Look through the window at the bottom of the heater. If there’s no small blue flame, relight it following the instructions on the heater’s label. Newer heaters may use an electronic igniter instead; see how to light a water heater with an electronic pilot.
- Check the gas valve and supply. Make sure the control knob is on “On” (not “Pilot” or “Off”) and that other gas appliances work. See what pilot mode means.
- If the pilot won’t stay lit, the thermocouple or flame sensor is the usual culprit, or a dirty pilot assembly. Many homeowners replace a thermocouple themselves, but call a pro if you’re unsure.
- Check the status light on electronic gas valves; blink codes are listed on the heater’s label or manual.
Not enough hot water
- Lower element failed (electric): you get a small amount of hot water that runs out quickly.
- Sediment takes up space and insulates the burner or element from the water. Flush the tank; see how to flush a water heater.
- Broken dip tube: cold incoming water mixes with the hot water at the top.
- Heater too small for your household or a new big tub. Check the first-hour rating against your peak use. See how long hot water lasts.
- Thermostat set low: the US Department of Energy recommends about 120°F for most homes.
Strange noises
- Rumbling, popping or crackling: water trapped under sediment boils and bursts. Flushing usually helps; heavy buildup in an older heater may not clear.
- Sizzling or hissing (electric): scale on the elements, or water dripping onto a hot element or burner. Check for leaks.
- Ticking or tapping: pipes expanding and contracting, or heat-trap nipples; usually harmless.
- Screeching: a partly closed valve restricting flow.
Smells and discolored water
Rotten egg smell from the hot tap only: according to North Dakota State University Extension, sulfates in the water can react with a magnesium anode rod to make hydrogen sulfide gas. The usual fix is to replace the anode with an aluminum (or aluminum/zinc) or powered anode. Don’t simply remove the anode without checking your warranty; it protects the tank from corrosion. If the smell is in both hot and cold water, the source is the water supply, so get it tested.
Rusty water from the hot tap: often a depleted anode rod or a corroding tank. If the heater is more than about 10 years old, start planning a replacement. See signs your water heater is going bad.
Leaks
| Where | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Pipe connections on top | Loose fittings or corroded nipples | Tighten or replace fittings |
| Temperature and pressure (T&P) relief valve | High temperature or pressure, faulty valve, thermal expansion | Lower the temperature, check for an expansion tank, have the valve tested or replaced. Never plug it. |
| Drain valve | Valve not fully closed or a worn washer | Close it or replace the valve or washer |
| Bottom of the tank | Tank corrosion | Replace the heater |
More detail: electric water heater leaking and how to use the water heater shutoff valve.
Repair or replace?
Thermostats, elements, thermocouples, anode rods and valves are inexpensive to replace. A leaking tank, a heater over about 10 to 12 years old with repeated problems, or a repair costing half the price of a new heater usually means it’s time to replace. See how long water heaters last and water heater replacement cost.
Multimeters on Amazon → | Aluminum/zinc anode rods → | Thermocouples →
Frequently asked questions
Why is my water heater not heating?
For electric heaters: a tripped breaker, a tripped reset button, or a failed element or thermostat. For gas heaters: the pilot is out or a faulty thermocouple won’t let it stay lit.
Where is the reset button on a water heater?
On most electric tank heaters it’s a red button behind the upper access panel, above the upper thermostat. Turn off the power before removing the panel.
Why does my hot water run out so fast?
Usually a failed lower element (electric), sediment buildup, a broken dip tube, or a heater too small for your household.
Is a noisy water heater dangerous?
Rumbling and popping usually mean sediment, which wastes energy and stresses the tank but isn’t immediately dangerous. A leaking T&P valve or a gas smell needs attention right away.
What temperature should a water heater be set to?
About 120°F for most households, according to the US Department of Energy. It saves energy, slows scale and reduces scald risk.
Sources: A.O. Smith “No hot water” troubleshooting guide, US Department of Energy water heating tips, North Dakota State University Extension (rotten egg odor from the hot water tap), GE Appliances water heater support. Work on gas lines and 240-volt wiring can be dangerous; call a licensed professional if you’re unsure.